Mount Virtus

"Happy to come back to Michigan, but I miss the mountains!"

Ben on Social Media

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Home
  • About Ben
  • Mount Virtus?
  • Writer / Editor For Hire
  • What I’m Thankful For
  • Colorado Ballot Reviews
    • Colorado Ballot 2008
    • Colorado Ballot 2010
    • Colorado Ballot 2012
  • Archives
  • Passion and Purpose:
    The Rise & Fall of Al Gansee
  • Mary and Jacob: From the Forgotten Dust
Home clean government Sorry, David: Even the Strongest Case Against Amendment 49 is Very Weak

9/22/2008 By Ben Leave a Comment

Sorry, David: Even the Strongest Case Against Amendment 49 is Very Weak

Rank liberal blogger David Thielen among the confused and misinformed about Amendment 49. Now David and I have a cordial relationship, so the misinformation and illogic in his attack on Amendment 49 deserve a cordial response.

First, though, I have to say David did the most admirable job I have yet seen in trying to argue against the Ethical Standards Initiative. His case is miles ahead of the deception and hypocrisy in the well-heeled opposition Protect Colorado’s Culture of Corruption Future.

Nevertheless, David still comes up short. His primary problem is rooted in the fact that he thinks Amendment 49 somehow will affect the Colorado Labor Peace Act. Simply put, it doesn’t. (Read the ballot language for yourself.) Even so, David goes as far as to offer a quote from the Chamber of Commerce [his link is broken, so I’m not sure to which Chamber he’s referring] about the importance of the Labor Peace Act. That’s fine, but no reason to oppose Amendment 49. Else, why would the Denver Metro Chamber of Commerce and Colorado Springs Chamber of Commerce both endorse the good-government initiative?

David writes that Amendment 49 “is an attempt to reduce the power of the unions pure & simple.” This simply is a rhetorical and unanswerable question of motive, a common liberal fallacy to make judgments based on opinions of intentions. It’s an assumption, and may in fact be true of some supporters, but shouldn’t sway any clear-thinking Colorado voter to take a stand on either side.

If supporters’ motives were to clean up government, should that be the sole basis on which the amendment is judged? I don’t believe David would think so. But its practical impacts can be judged in the facts that numerous local Colorado governments – including 12 counties representing more than half the state’s population – have successfully passed the measure without the negative fallout some scaremongers have predicted for Amendment 49.

Will Amendment 49 affect unions? Indirectly, as it will also affect other professional associations and lobbying organizations. Amendment 49 is essentially a restriction on government’s ability to collect and bundle money for political groups. If unions are most affected, it is only because they have taken most advantage of the scheme.

To the title of David’s post, will Amendment 49 somehow “eliminate public employee unions”? Only if these unions are doing such a dismal job that when they ask their members for money through a direct private payment, rather than benefiting from an automatic government payroll deduction, the members will say No. If the union has proven its value to its membership, collecting dues through a private method as opposed to a government method should make little or no difference.

As public school employee Michael at Best Destiny explains about Amendment 49:

Personally, I don’t see the big deal. It’s certainly not the end of the world. If the union is really doing its job and representing its people, than the people shouldn’t have any problem signing the slip of paper at their bank that makes it possible to just hand the money over.

On the other hand, if people realize how little their unions actually do for them compared to the budget they operate under, maybe this really IS a big deal.

If Amendment 49 passes, only one thing is assured: government quits being the middleman in the dues collection process for labor unions and professional associations. Public employee unions are only “eliminated” if they utterly fail to represent the workers they purport to represent. And in that extreme and unlikely case, which David wants us to believe is the inevitable result of the initiative, newer and more accountable unions and other membership organizations would fill the void. Because Amendment 49 allows public employees to retain all their essential rights to join or not to join, to pay dues or not to pay dues.

So since there is no harm to Colorado public employees, why is David so fearful about Amendment 49? I won’t assume to know the answer. But maybe he can elaborate.

Filed Under: clean government, Colorado Politics, General, Labor Tagged With: Amendment 49, assumptions, attack, automatic payroll deduction, Best Destiny, Colorado Springs Chamber of Commerce, Colorado voters, confused, cordial, David Thielen, deception, Denver Metro Chamber of Commerce, dues collection, endorsements, Ethical Standards initiative, hypocrisy, illogic, Labor Peace Act, labor unions, liberal blogger, liberal fallacy, lobbying organizations, membership, middleman, misinformation, motives, political groups, professional associations, Protect Colorado's Future, Public employee unions, public school employee, representation, well-heeled opposition

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inside

  • About Ben
  • Archives
  • Colorado Ballot Reviews
    • Colorado Ballot 2008
    • Colorado Ballot 2010
    • Colorado Ballot 2012
    • Colorado Ballot 2014
  • Mary and Jacob: From the Forgotten Dust
  • Mount Virtus?
  • Passion and Purpose:
    The Rise & Fall of Al Gansee
  • What I’m Thankful For
  • Writer / Editor For Hire

About Me

Ben DeGrow
Grateful and growing Christian, devoted husband and father of 3, public policy analyst, returned to Michigan by way of Colorado, conservative writer, lifelong learner, Detroit Tigers fan.

Recent Posts

  • AI-Enhanced Cyberbullying: The Dark Side of Teen Innovation
  • My Baker’s Dozen of Top 2023 Reads
  • Common Learning Disabilities in Children
  • Tips to Teach Kids to Set and Achieve Goals
  • The Christmas Music Countdown You’ve Been Looking For: 2022 Edition

Colorado News

  • Colorado Senate News
  • Complete Colorado
  • Independence Institute
  • Loveland Politics
  • The Colorado Observer

National News and Politics

  • Drudge Report
  • Hot Air
  • National Review
  • Politico
  • Real Clear Politics
  • Reason
  • The Washington Times
  • TownHall
  • Wall Street Journal
  • Weekly Standard
  • World Magazine

Blogs Extraordinaire

  • American Thinker
  • David Harsanyi’s Blog
  • E!! The True Conservative Story
  • EIA Intercepts
  • Evangelical Outpost
  • Hugh Hewitt
  • Instapundit
  • LaShawn Barber
  • Lileks
  • Little Green Footballs
  • Michelle Malkin
  • NRO's The Corner
  • Power Line
  • Red State

Completing the Blogroll

  • Alarming News
  • Black Five
  • Blogs of War
  • Eduwonk
  • Flypaper
  • Fraters Libertas
  • Historical Conversations
  • IMAO
  • Jay P. Greene
  • Mike Anderson
  • Mullings
  • Professor Bainbridge
  • Right Thinking
  • Right Wing News
  • Right Wing Nuthouse
  • Shot in the Dark
  • Talking Points Memo
  • Virginia Postrel
  • Volokh Conspiracy

Christian Commentary et al.

  • Kevin Pierpont
  • Sharper Iron

Conservative and GOP Sites

  • Backbone America
  • Cal Thomas
  • Colorado Republican Party
  • Colorado Republican Study Committee
  • Dennis Prager
  • Denver Metro Young Republicans
  • Free Republic
  • Heritage Foundation
  • Jefferson County Republican Party
  • Mackinac Center for Public Policy
  • Mark Steyn
  • Michael Medved
  • Rush Limbaugh

Colorado Blogs

  • American Kestrel
  • Bob Agard
  • Colorado Charter Schools
  • Colorado Peak Politics
  • Colorado Pols
  • Colorado Right
  • Conservative Libertarian Outpost
  • Coyote Gulch
  • Ed Is Watching
  • Free Colorado
  • Jeff Crank Show
  • Mark Hillman
  • Patient Power
  • PirateBallerina
  • Protein Wisdom
  • Reagan Girl
  • Rocky Mountain Alliance 1.0 (Archive)
  • Rocky Mountain Alliance 2.0 (Archive)
  • Rossputin
  • Stop the ACLU Blog
  • The Spot (Denver Post)
  • We Stand Firm

Other Sites

  • Technorati
  • Word Press

Rocky Mountain Alliance 2.0

  • Reclaim the Blue
  • The Business Word
  • The Daily Blogster
  • View from a Height

To Contact Me:
bendegrow-at-gmail.com

Copyright © 2025 RSS Feed · WordPress · Log in