Mount Virtus

"Happy to come back to Michigan, but I miss the mountains!"

Ben on Social Media

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Home
  • About Ben
  • Mount Virtus?
  • Writer / Editor For Hire
  • What I’m Thankful For
  • Colorado Ballot Reviews
    • Colorado Ballot 2008
    • Colorado Ballot 2010
    • Colorado Ballot 2012
  • Archives
  • Passion and Purpose:
    The Rise & Fall of Al Gansee
  • Mary and Jacob: From the Forgotten Dust
  • The Westfield Gardener
Home Colorado Politics Revising and Extending My Remarks on State Government Unionization

4/11/2008 By Ben 1 Comment

Revising and Extending My Remarks on State Government Unionization

Today, two Colorado newspapers ran stories about growing unionization in state government. I was quoted in both articles, as the issue is one I’ve researched and have an Independence Institute publication being formatted for official release on Monday. There’s only so much space in a news article. But that’s what makes a blog a wonderful venue for revising and extending my remarks, as a way to press the debate forward.

First, Chris Barge in the Rocky Mountain News introduces the issue:

The unions that pushed the hardest for Gov. Bill Ritter’s executive order granting them a larger voice in state government could soon see a nearly fourfold increase in membership….

The unions, which had fewer than 6,000 dues-paying state workers on their rolls before the Nov. 2 order, could soon exclusively represent the vast majority of the state’s 32,000 qualifying workers.

Then the part where yours truly comes in:

Benjamin DeGrow, education policy analyst at the conservative Independence Institute, plans to release a competing report on Monday called “A Shaky Foundation, a Potential Threat: Analyzing Colorado State Union ‘Employee Partnerships.’ “

He argues that Ritter’s executive order granting union representation through so-called “partnership agreements” is misguided, unnecessary and ultimately will result in unions holding Ritter and lawmakers hostage to their demands for higher wages and benefits.

Ritter has emphasized that his order specifically bans strikes, prohibits binding arbitration and bars unions from charging dues to nonmembers. Last week he signed a state worker strike ban into law.

Unfortunately, Gov. Bill Ritter only gets credit for one out of three on that recycled claim.

Yes, Ritter’s executive order essentially prohibits binding arbitration, so he gets that one right. Even so, I explain that the order may lead us to binding arbitration. That’s in today’s other article, a Colorado Springs Gazette piece written by Ed Sealover:

Ben DeGrow, a policy analyst with the conservative Independence Institute, argued, however, that permitting partnerships opens the door to further allowances, including binding arbitration.

And that’s Ritter’s strongest claim of the three. As to the other two, the executive order’s strike ban was useless and required legislation to fix – legislation the governor signed last week with no enforceable consequences, legislation that ends up having the same effect as the ban on adultery.

Third, the claim that the order “bars unions from charging dues to nonmembers” is entirely inaccurate. The order is completely silent on the issue. If Ritter wanted to protect non-member workers from paying unwanted fees, he could have explicitly written it into the order. Instead, dissenting state employees are left subject to the whim of a private negotiation process.

A point I emphasized to both reporters, a point that didn’t make the cut, was that union certification requires a simple majority of ballots cast – not a true majority of affected employees. State workers have to make their voice heard in the election. A non-vote is not a vote against representation.

The Gazette story observed:

The group representing 709 Colorado State Patrol employees voted overwhelmingly last month to be represented by the Association of Colorado State Patrol Professionals.

While ACSPP did win 75 percent of the ballots cast, only 431 ballots were cast. That means 324 out of 709 troopers (or about 46 percent) approved union representation.

One final clip from the Gazette that merits a response:

Colorado is 49th in the country in employer contribution to state workers’ individual health coverage.

This isn’t the venue to expand on the health care reform debate. No one is going to deny that the cost of health insurance premiums has been rising at an uncomfortable rate for many families. But Colorado state employees are far from uniquely affected by the problem.

The 49th ranking (49th? Where have I heard that before?) is misleading for at least one major reason: The comparison is made using an HMO plan, but most Colorado state employees subscribe to the family PPO plan. Colorado state employees pay a smaller share of the family PPO premium than the regional average. Their health benefits are not stellar and gold-plated, but they are certainly not as stingy as advertised.

Subtracting health insurance premiums from wages, and adjusting for cost of living, Colorado state employees are better compensated than state employees in six of seven neighboring states (and just a whisker behind Nebraska), and on average earn 3.8 percent more than workers in Colorado’s private sector.

But didn’t Gov. Ritter say his union “partnerships” weren’t about increasing wages and benefits? Too bad the union leaders know, and have advertised, that his order leaves negotiations open to these topics.

Well, anyway, stay tuned: the final Independence Institute report will have all the details. I’ll let you know when it’s online and ready to be viewed.

Filed Under: Colorado Politics, General, Labor, My Life Tagged With: Colorado Springs Gazette, Executive Order, Gov. Bill Ritter, Independence Institute, Rocky Mountain News, unionization

Comments

  1. Bob Agard says

    4/11/2008 at 5:10 pm

    Your in depth analysis is greatly appreciated.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inside

  • About Ben
  • Archives
  • Colorado Ballot Reviews
    • Colorado Ballot 2008
    • Colorado Ballot 2010
    • Colorado Ballot 2012
    • Colorado Ballot 2014
  • Mary and Jacob: From the Forgotten Dust
  • Mount Virtus?
  • Passion and Purpose:
    The Rise & Fall of Al Gansee
  • The Westfield Gardener
  • What I’m Thankful For
  • Writer / Editor For Hire

About Me

Ben DeGrow
Grateful and growing Christian, devoted husband and father of 3, public policy analyst, returned to Michigan by way of Colorado, conservative writer, lifelong learner, Detroit Tigers fan.

Recent Posts

  • AI-Enhanced Cyberbullying: The Dark Side of Teen Innovation
  • My Baker’s Dozen of Top 2023 Reads
  • Common Learning Disabilities in Children
  • Tips to Teach Kids to Set and Achieve Goals
  • The Christmas Music Countdown You’ve Been Looking For: 2022 Edition

Colorado News

  • Colorado Senate News
  • Complete Colorado
  • Independence Institute
  • Loveland Politics
  • The Colorado Observer

National News and Politics

  • Drudge Report
  • Hot Air
  • National Review
  • Politico
  • Real Clear Politics
  • Reason
  • The Washington Times
  • TownHall
  • Wall Street Journal
  • Weekly Standard
  • World Magazine

Blogs Extraordinaire

  • American Thinker
  • David Harsanyi’s Blog
  • E!! The True Conservative Story
  • EIA Intercepts
  • Evangelical Outpost
  • Hugh Hewitt
  • Instapundit
  • LaShawn Barber
  • Lileks
  • Little Green Footballs
  • Michelle Malkin
  • NRO's The Corner
  • Power Line
  • Red State

Completing the Blogroll

  • Alarming News
  • Black Five
  • Blogs of War
  • Eduwonk
  • Flypaper
  • Fraters Libertas
  • Historical Conversations
  • IMAO
  • Jay P. Greene
  • Mike Anderson
  • Mullings
  • Professor Bainbridge
  • Right Thinking
  • Right Wing News
  • Right Wing Nuthouse
  • Shot in the Dark
  • Talking Points Memo
  • Virginia Postrel
  • Volokh Conspiracy

Christian Commentary et al.

  • Kevin Pierpont
  • Sharper Iron

Conservative and GOP Sites

  • Backbone America
  • Cal Thomas
  • Colorado Republican Party
  • Colorado Republican Study Committee
  • Dennis Prager
  • Denver Metro Young Republicans
  • Free Republic
  • Heritage Foundation
  • Jefferson County Republican Party
  • Mackinac Center for Public Policy
  • Mark Steyn
  • Michael Medved
  • Rush Limbaugh

Colorado Blogs

  • American Kestrel
  • Bob Agard
  • Colorado Charter Schools
  • Colorado Peak Politics
  • Colorado Pols
  • Colorado Right
  • Conservative Libertarian Outpost
  • Coyote Gulch
  • Ed Is Watching
  • Free Colorado
  • Jeff Crank Show
  • Mark Hillman
  • Patient Power
  • PirateBallerina
  • Protein Wisdom
  • Reagan Girl
  • Rocky Mountain Alliance 1.0 (Archive)
  • Rocky Mountain Alliance 2.0 (Archive)
  • Rossputin
  • Stop the ACLU Blog
  • The Spot (Denver Post)
  • We Stand Firm

Other Sites

  • Technorati
  • Word Press

Rocky Mountain Alliance 2.0

  • Reclaim the Blue
  • The Business Word
  • The Daily Blogster
  • View from a Height

To Contact Me:
bendegrow-at-gmail.com

Copyright © 2025 RSS Feed · WordPress · Log in