Mount Virtus

"Happy to come back to Michigan, but I miss the mountains!"

Ben on Social Media

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Home
  • About Ben
  • Mount Virtus?
  • Writer / Editor For Hire
  • What I’m Thankful For
  • Colorado Ballot Reviews
    • Colorado Ballot 2008
    • Colorado Ballot 2010
    • Colorado Ballot 2012
  • Archives
  • Passion and Purpose:
    The Rise & Fall of Al Gansee
  • Mary and Jacob: From the Forgotten Dust
Home Christianity and Faith “Keep That Bible Out of The Jury Room”

3/29/2005 By Ben 3 Comments

“Keep That Bible Out of The Jury Room”

A man was clearly convicted of a heinous murder. A jury of his peers, guided by the dictates of Colorado law and their consciences unanimously approved the death penalty. An Adams County district judge overturned the death penalty because the jury’s decision was in some small degree informed by reading Bible passages.

Yesterday, the morally-confused Colorado Supreme Court upheld the judge’s decision.

My question: what if jurors had consulted Bible passages that convinced them the murderer deserved clemency? Like the recent US Supreme Court decision written by Anthony Kennedy regarding the juvenile death penalty, though, it’s not as much the substance of the issue that was decided as much as the reasoning that led the majority of the justices to the conclusion.

From Justice Gregory Hobbs’ majority opinion:

Some jurors may view biblical texts like the Leviticus passage at issue here as a factual representation of God’s will. The text may also be viewed as a legal instruction, issuing from God, requiring a particular and mandatory punishment for murder.

The sane response from dissenting Justice Nancy Rice:

To presume that jurors who have a religious background cannot distinguish between the written biblical passages referenced here and the written jury instructions . . . is to underestimate their intelligence and to belittle their participation in our legal system.

Thanks, Justice Rice, for the eloquent common-sense (yet also steeped in legal precedent) dissent. The point of contention is whether the jurors’ exposure to Romans 13:1 – “Let every soul be subject to the higher powers….” – and Leviticus 24:20-21 – “…eye for eye, tooth for tooth…” – constituted “prejudicial treatment” of the convicted murder and his sentence. She rightly deemed such a contention absurd and dismantled the majority’s argument by, among other things, looking at the Bible passages in question.

Jury members were instructed, as required under law, to “apply reasoned judgment” and to “make a further individual moral assessment” of the case. Apparently, three Colorado Supreme Court justices believe that a person cannot make a reasoned judgment or a moral assessment when influenced by the Bible in its written form.

Justice Rice cited a well-accepted biblical commentary to demonstrate the ironic fact that in consulting Romans 13:1 a juror was being instructed “to follow the laws of Colorado.” If only the majority of our state’s highest court could be so motivated.

Filed Under: Christianity and Faith, Colorado Politics, General

Comments

  1. Mario Nicolais says

    3/29/2005 at 9:25 am

    Ben-

    Beat me to it. Strange that the most divine law can actually make a jury trial sentence “unfair”…

  2. Mark says

    3/29/2005 at 9:08 pm

    Apparently judges are very selective of what documents a juror can consult. If only they would constrain themselves to United States case law and most importantly the Constitution! Good post Ben.

  3. James C. Hess says

    3/30/2005 at 5:54 pm

    And what of the unabashed contempt Channel 9 News demonstrates toward the woman who carried the bible?

    Heavens.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Inside

  • About Ben
  • Archives
  • Colorado Ballot Reviews
    • Colorado Ballot 2008
    • Colorado Ballot 2010
    • Colorado Ballot 2012
    • Colorado Ballot 2014
  • Mary and Jacob: From the Forgotten Dust
  • Mount Virtus?
  • Passion and Purpose:
    The Rise & Fall of Al Gansee
  • What I’m Thankful For
  • Writer / Editor For Hire

About Me

Ben DeGrow
Grateful and growing Christian, devoted husband and father of 3, public policy analyst, returned to Michigan by way of Colorado, conservative writer, lifelong learner, Detroit Tigers fan.

Recent Posts

  • Tips to Teach Kids to Set and Achieve Goals
  • The Christmas Music Countdown You’ve Been Looking For: 2022 Edition
  • Sleep Deprivation and Parental Controls: How to Ensure Your Kids are Safe from Media Exposure
  • 8 Original Ways To Leverage Influencer Marketing
  • Why Every Single Business Needs A YouTube Channel

Colorado News

  • Colorado Senate News
  • Complete Colorado
  • Independence Institute
  • Loveland Politics
  • The Colorado Observer

National News and Politics

  • Drudge Report
  • Hot Air
  • National Review
  • Politico
  • Real Clear Politics
  • Reason
  • The Washington Times
  • TownHall
  • Wall Street Journal
  • Weekly Standard
  • World Magazine

Blogs Extraordinaire

  • American Thinker
  • David Harsanyi’s Blog
  • E!! The True Conservative Story
  • EIA Intercepts
  • Evangelical Outpost
  • Hugh Hewitt
  • Instapundit
  • LaShawn Barber
  • Lileks
  • Little Green Footballs
  • Michelle Malkin
  • NRO's The Corner
  • Power Line
  • Red State

Completing the Blogroll

  • Alarming News
  • Black Five
  • Blogs of War
  • Eduwonk
  • Flypaper
  • Fraters Libertas
  • Historical Conversations
  • IMAO
  • Jay P. Greene
  • Mike Anderson
  • Mullings
  • Professor Bainbridge
  • Right Thinking
  • Right Wing News
  • Right Wing Nuthouse
  • Shot in the Dark
  • Talking Points Memo
  • Virginia Postrel
  • Volokh Conspiracy

Christian Commentary et al.

  • Kevin Pierpont
  • Sharper Iron

Conservative and GOP Sites

  • Backbone America
  • Cal Thomas
  • Colorado Republican Party
  • Colorado Republican Study Committee
  • Dennis Prager
  • Denver Metro Young Republicans
  • Free Republic
  • Heritage Foundation
  • Jefferson County Republican Party
  • Mackinac Center for Public Policy
  • Mark Steyn
  • Michael Medved
  • Rush Limbaugh

Colorado Blogs

  • American Kestrel
  • Bob Agard
  • Colorado Charter Schools
  • Colorado Peak Politics
  • Colorado Pols
  • Colorado Right
  • Conservative Libertarian Outpost
  • Coyote Gulch
  • Ed Is Watching
  • Free Colorado
  • Jeff Crank Show
  • Mark Hillman
  • Patient Power
  • PirateBallerina
  • Protein Wisdom
  • Reagan Girl
  • Rocky Mountain Alliance 1.0 (Archive)
  • Rocky Mountain Alliance 2.0 (Archive)
  • Rossputin
  • Stop the ACLU Blog
  • The Spot (Denver Post)
  • We Stand Firm

Other Sites

  • Technorati
  • Word Press

Rocky Mountain Alliance 2.0

  • Reclaim the Blue
  • The Business Word
  • The Daily Blogster
  • View from a Height

To Contact Me:
bendegrow-at-gmail.com

Copyright © 2023 RSS Feed · WordPress · Log in