Archive for March, 2008

Second Look at Health Insurance Statistic: One Coloradan Dying Per Day?

Posted on March 26th, 2008 in Colorado Politics, General, Health Care, National Politics | 2 Comments »

The Rocky Mountain News reports:

Each day in Colorado one person dies unnecessarily because he or she doesn't have health insurance, a group advocating universal coverage said Tuesday.

The nonprofit Families USA used a 30-year study of deaths and insurance status to reach the conclusion that 360 Coloradans die prematurely every year because they didn't have health insurance.

The assumption, based on death statistics, is that a person without coverage has a 25 percent greater chance of dying prematurely.

So when it comes to health care reform, it's safe to assume that it would be better to do almost anything than nothing at all - right? Not so fast.

Unfortunately, there are several problems with this report. Besides the assumption stated in the article, the report also uncritically restates the figures of "47 million uninsured," without explaining the fact that many of those are only temporarily uninsured, are illegal aliens, or are eligible for government insurance programs and don't apply.

So even presuming their statistic is accurate, the question remains how many people die from their own neglect as opposed to government neglect. Nor can an inference be made from the Families USA statistic that simply mandating universal health insurance coverage for all would lower the death rate accordingly - if at all. Any such reform would have an adverse effect on the cost and quality of health care. This survey simply didn't compare the estimated death rate effects of the status quo versus any sort of proposed reform, including Families USA's preferred pet of universal health insurance coverage.

Finally, the statistic itself seems to be derived from something less than a concrete scientific method, as pointed out by my Independence Institute colleague in the Rocky:

Linda Gorman, health policy analyst for the free-market think tank the Independence Institute, has been a vocal critic of reports that purport to enumerate the lives lost to lack of insurance coverage, saying it is simply guesswork.

Gorman, who served on Colorado's Blue Ribbon Commission on Health Care Reform, says government-sponsored health care will be inefficient and raise taxes so much that care will have to be rationed.

That could lead to, say, no more hip replacements or knee replacements after a certain age, and to long lines to wait for treatment, she has said.

The touted report needs to be dissected carefully and critically, but you can expect Colorado's typical Lefty suspects to tout the statistic both as the gospel and as airtight proof for universal health insurance - despite their suspect track record. More work needs to be done examining these claims and comparing them to the effects of various proposed reforms, and preferably not done alone by a group committed to advocacy for more government in health care.

I.I.’s Free Market Minute Debuts, Debunks Health Care Figure

Posted on March 25th, 2008 in Colorado Politics, General | 1 Comment »

As in any debate, the debate over health care reform in Colorado demands the use of honest facts. But a group called Partnership for a Healthy Colorado has misstated the facts. So demonstrates the inaugural edition of the Independence Institute‘s “Free Market Minute” video series:

Ouch. Facts are stubborn things. And good public policy depends on good facts, rightly understood. The implications for health care reform are real, and will affect real Colorado families and businesses. Shouldn’t we be sure our facts are straight first?

Top Initiative on Colorado’s 2008 Ballot: Yes on Amendment 46

Posted on March 25th, 2008 in Colorado Politics, Cultural Conservatism, General, National Politics | No Comments »

From the Rocky Mountain News today:

The secretary of state certified a measure for the Nov. 4 ballot Monday that would ban race and gender-based hiring preferences in Colorado.

Supporters of the the measure, Amendment 46, submitted 128,744 signatures March 10. On Monday, Secretary of State Mike Coffman declared that a random sampling showed that enough of them were valid.

The measure is pushed by Ward Connerly, a black Republican who has been vilified by civil rights groups for supporting anti-affirmative action policies. Connerly has led similar successful initiatives in California, Washington and Michigan. Supporters say that the measure’s language mirrors the 1964 Civil Rights Act.

This should mean Connerly’s Civil Rights Initiative appears as the first initiative on the November 2008 state ballot. Here’s the ballot language, embodying the timeless principle of Equality Under the Law, a principle which time has come.

LaShawn Barber reminds readers how the same initiative has succeeded at the ballot box in states that lean further Left than Colorado:

Liberal Californians voted against preferences in government hiring, contracting, and admissions by 54 percent in 1996. So did 58.3 percent of voters in Washington state in 1998 and 58 percent of Michigan voters in 2006.

The election is 32 weeks away, but here’s one of the very first recommendations to vote Yes on Amendment 46.

Iowa, Like Colorado, Bending to Government Employee Union Pressure

Posted on March 25th, 2008 in Colorado Politics, General, Labor, National Politics | No Comments »

The pressure to expand the power of government employee union officials at the expense of taxpayers is not isolated to Colorado. The Des Moines Register reports:

Ignoring pleas from the governor and a slew of local elected officials to give Iowans time to weigh in, Democrats in the Iowa Senate today approved a labor-backed bill that would give unions more power at the negotiating table.

House File 2645 would give public employees the same power as managers to open up contract talks to almost any workplace subject. The Senate approved the bill on a 27-23 vote.

Six days passed between when this proposal was offered and the bill’s passage by both chambers. It marks the first substantial change since the collective bargaining law was written in 1974.

In both places the pro-union political forces have pushed their proposals forward on the fast track. Democrat Gov. Chet Culver expressed uneasiness at the fact that Iowa’s legislature rushed the collective bargaining bill in a mere six days, but at least their legislature got to debate the issue at all. Here in Colorado, our own Democrat Gov. Bill Ritter reshaped public employee labor law in union officials’ favor by executive order.

More of the change that Democrats have to offer.

Colorado Democrats Stick It to Taxpayers AND College Students

Posted on March 25th, 2008 in Colorado Politics, Education, General | No Comments »

With Democrats in charge at the State Capitol, we get more reminders than we would like about their party leaders’ priorities: 1) Stick it to the taxpayer on the collection end; and 2) Use personal politics to stick it to certain users of state services on the distribution end. What does this add up to? Average Colorado citizens like you and I get stuck.

This morning’s reminder comes via Rocky Mountain Right, as it appears that statehouse Democrat lawmakers are using their dislike of new University of Colorado president Bruce Benson to undercut the students and faculty on Denver’s Auraria campus. Yes, Auraria funding was arbitrarily revoked, leaving a $120 million science facility construction site uncompleted.

If you recall, during the 2005 Referendum C tax hike election, Coloradans were told college students’ costs would rise if the measure didn’t pass – as the humorous Andrew Ripemoff reminds us:

In an October 6, 2005 Denver Post article, taxpayers were warned that failure to pass Ref. C could result in, (and this is a direct quote): “…possible tuition increases as high as $423 per semester for Colorado residents at the Boulder campus.” That sounds really ominous huh?

But now we know this new 9 1/2 percent tuition hike will mean that a student taking 15 hours of, say, engineering classes at CU-Boulder will see a tuition increase of $482.98 per semester. I see you’re eyes are glazing over, so let me diagram this out for you:

Democrat Talking Points:

Before Ref. C:
“You MUST vote for this. If not, tuition will be raised $423 per semester.”

After Ref. C passes:
“Thanks for your vote, but we’re going to raise tuition $482 per semester anyway.”

Isn’t that funny? You’d pay LESS tuition had Ref. C failed. Don’t you love the irony? Oh, um. Gosh. Sorry. OK, OK. I’m just the messenger. I, I, I can’t breathe. Can you please take your hands off my throat.

Taxpayers pay more. Students pay more. Yet the Democrats’ proposed state budget includes adding 1,334 new employees. Power and patronage are Democrat priorities. Forget the rest of us.

My Marital Happiness Explained

Posted on March 24th, 2008 in General, My Life, Random and Miscellaneous | No Comments »

Now I get it. And here I thought it might have something to do with a deep personal compatibility or ongoing spiritual commitment … or even those kind words, flowers and gifts. Now I have a factor outside my control to thank.

Samsphere: Windy City Blogging

Posted on March 24th, 2008 in General, My Life | 2 Comments »

I have accepted an invitation to appear at a national conference of free market / limited-government bloggers. It’s off to the 1st Annual Samsphere Chicago event this weekend:

Samsphere is a new media forum, hosted by the Sam Adams Alliance, where bloggers and e-activists from across the country can gather together to network and share ideas. Samsphere will be specifically geared toward bloggers and e-activists who focus on local and state-level politics, and who are dedicated to the principles of individual freedom and limited government.

For the hard-core Lefties, yes, Samsphere is the shadowy Vast Right Wing Conspiracy in action. For the rest of my readers, it’s not so secretive as all that. It will be an opportunity to expand the limited government / pro-freedom blogging community, in hopes of meeting the following fine bloggers from across the nation:

Erick Erickson * RedState * National
Allen Fuller * Flat Creek Management * National
John Fund * Wall Street Journal * National
Brad Jones * Face the State * National
Jenn Sierra * Fort Hard Knox * National
Erik Telford * Americans for Prosperity * National
E.M. Zanotti * American Princess * National
Bill Smith * ARRA News Service * Arkansas
Ben DeGrow * Mount Virtus * Colorado
Mark Johnson * ILGOPnet * Illinois
Doug Welch * Stix * Illinois
Bob Weeks * Wichita Liberty * Kansas
Earl Glynn * Kansas Meadowlark * Kansas
Jeff Blanco * Louisiana Conservative * Louisiana
Lance Dutson * Maine Web Report * Maine
Jack McHugh * Mackinac Center * Michigan
Chet Zarko * Outside Lansing * Michigan
Jim Hoft * Gateway Pundit * Missouri
Craig Sprout * Montana Politics * Montana
Chuck Muth * Muth’s Truths * Nevada
Skip Murphy * Granite Grok * New Hampshire
Mario Burgos * Mario Burgos * New Mexico
Maggie Thurber * Thurber’s Thoughts * Ohio
Chris Arps * Oklahoma Political News Service * Oklahoma
Trent Siebert * Tennessee Policy Institute * Tennessee
Leslie Carbone * Leslie Carbone * Virginia
Don Ward * Sound Politics * Washington
Fred Dooley * Real Debate Wisconsin * Wisconsin
Tristen Cramer * Haemet * Wyoming
Chad Everson * Grizzly Groundswell * Minnesota
Steve Sibson * Sibby Online * South Dakota

I hope to interview some of them for my site’s readers, as we share ideas and best practices on a broader scale. I also hope to pass on what’s happening on this side of the Colorado blogosphere. Let me know if you think of anything important to pass on.

Yes, we have let the Left get ahead in this area, but their advantage is waning. Our strength lies in ideas. Forward, then.

Union Bosses Act Like State Property Owners Under Ritter’s Order

Posted on March 24th, 2008 in Colorado Politics, General, Labor | No Comments »

Face the State has the skinny on “Colorado WINS” union bosses acting like they own state government property:

An executive order, signed by Gov. Bill Ritter, a Democrat, last November, empowered unions to serve as “exclusive representatives” of state employees for the purposes of forming “employee partnerships.” Days after the order, a coalition of three major unions – CAPE-SEIU, AFSCME, and the American Federation of Teachers – announced a cooperative agreement to organize state workers under the name “Colorado WINS.”

After hearing from state employees that Colorado WINS is aggressively trying to organize an election, Face The State attempted to attend an on-site meeting between the union and state employees. Face The State had cleared its attendance with Dawn Lee, the media contact at Colorado WINS. Then minutes before the meeting, Lee contacted FTS to say that the government building where it was being held had restricted access and she was unable to clear the attendance of a FTS staff writer without performing a background check, for which there was not enough time.

In response, FTS contacted Julie Postlethwait, the public information officer for the Department of Personnel, to confirm Lee’s claim. Postlethwait said that FTS’s presence at the meeting was not a problem, yet when FTS staff writer, Rachel Boxer, arrived to cover the meeting, she was denied access at the door. After Boxer identified herself by name, a DPA employee told her she was not allowed into the meeting and needed to leave the building “immediately.”

According to Postlethwait, Colorado WINS had directed DPA staff to deny FTS access to its public meeting – an action that directly conflicted with the department’s orders. Postlethwait apologized to FTS for the breakdown in communication, and said that the reporter should have been let into the meeting.

It looks like Gov. Bill Ritter has given the union bosses reason to think they’re in charge. The story goes on to explain how they appear to have taken Ritter’s executive order as a license to move aggressively:

There are mounting complaints from state employees that the union is making a hard-line pitch for an election. Jimmie Cook, operations and maintenance manager at the state’s mental health facility in Pueblo, said that in the early days after the executive order, union organizers acted as though “they had free rein from the governor.” He said some of his employees reported incidents of being “accosted” by Colorado WINS representatives in the workplace parking lot. “Some went ahead and signed the petition just to get rid of them,” said Cook. He noted that a directive from the facility’s executive director has since halted the activity.

You have to wonder: Since Bill Ritter’s executive order, what else has been going on below the public radar? In the case of denying a reporter access to a meeting on state property, “Colorado WINS” clearly overstepped its bounds. And outside scrutiny has helped to ensure public officials will work toward remedying the problem. But what happens when no one is looking again?

What has Ritter unleashed?

Cross posted at Ritter Watch

Colorado Confidential Accuses U.S. Military Personnel of “Murder”?

Posted on March 24th, 2008 in Colorado Politics, Education, General, World Events | 2 Comments »

Today Colorado Confidential published a story by Kate Bernuth about a controversy developing at a small private Denver school. It starts as a typical foray into agenda journalism for the heavily Left-leaning site:

At a tiny international school in southeast Denver, a conflict is playing out that reflects, in a microcosm, the wider divisions in American society as the nation enters the sixth year of a bloody, unpopular war.

A display of photographs and a statement by the Iranian artist in the halls of Colorado International School has caused a dust-up between administrators and an outraged parent who accuses the school of spreading “anti-American propaganda.”

Every month at this language-immersion school of 44 students, most of whom are in pre-school and kindergarten, the customs, geography and language of one nation are highlighted with a special presentation. This month, to coincide with Persian New Year, the focus is on Iran, and the school invited Farhad Vakili Tabar to display photographs from his homeland.

Near the photos of the Iranian children is one image of an Iraqi boy named Ali Rekaad, a brief story of his life, and the date and time that he and his entire family were killed by a U.S. bomb. Underneath is artist Farhad Vakili Tabar’s stated purpose for the collection of photographs:

“By showing the portraits of some Iranian children, I hope to bring up the faces of thousands of Iraqi children who have died, become orphans, handicapped or homeless in this war.” [emphasis added]

Moving beyond the clear agenda journalism in the story’s opening line, here is a picture of Tabar’s two posted writings – sent to me by the aggrieved parent – that stirred the controversy:
(more…)

“Democrat” Label Featured Less in Scandal Reporting: More Proof

Posted on March 22nd, 2008 in General, National Politics | 2 Comments »

Any fair-minded and honest observer of political events knows that neither major party has cornered the market on scandals. Public officials elected both as Republicans and Democrats have been exposed for various types of corruption, malfeasance, and other prominent moral failings. So why are major media outlets so unbalanced in their presentation?

Sure, anytime there is a salacious scandal or other revelation that results in the resignation of a big-city mayor, governor, or member of Congress, the news has to talk about it. But there has been a clear and measurable tendency on the media’s part to ignore the party label far more when the story is about a Democrat.

More proof emerges today: My Independence Institute colleague David Kopel compares the reporting of the Denver newspapers on the respective scandals surrounding Republican Congressman Mark Foley and Democrat New York Governor Eliot Spitzer:

In the Post, 25 stories revealed Foley’s party, and eight did not. So both papers mentioned Foley’s party more often than not, while the Post did so at a higher rate.

For coverage of Spitzer last week, the difference between the papers was astonishing. Seven stories in the Post (including print and online) said that Spitzer was a Democrat, and 15 did not.

In the Rocky last week, only three stories noted Spitzer’s party, and 24 did not. Spitzer’s party didn’t make it into the print edition of the Rocky until the Thursday story covering his resignation the day before.

So during the scandal coverage, both papers mentioned Spitzer’s party at a rate far below the rate of mentioning Foley’s party. [emphasis added]

And another item from Newsbusters begins:

The week after it took the NBC Nightly News until the fourth day of coverage to inform viewers that disgraced then-New York Governor Eliot Spitzer is a Democrat, Friday’s NBC Nightly News ran a full story on the scandalous behavior surrounding Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick, but never identified his political party.

Of course, the Motor City hasn’t had a Republican mayor since 1961. So NBC was just assuming its viewers knew Kilpatrick, the son of Democratic Congresswoman Carolyn Cheeks Kilpatrick, wasn’t a member of the Grand Old Party … Right? That would be a generous interpretation.

Grand Junction’s Gene Kinsey made the same catch about the NBC broadcast, beginning his post with the colorful remark:

Like the evil name of “Voldemort”, the name Democrat must not be spoken. That seems to be the subtext of many main stream media reports when it comes to the misdeeds of the chosen party.

Indeed. But who that makes Harry Potter, I don’t know.

Good Friday

Posted on March 21st, 2008 in Christianity and Faith, General | 1 Comment »

Serious reflections for Good Friday (all passages from the New American Standard Bible):

Romans 5:6-9
For while we were still helpless, at the right time Christ died for the ungodly. For one will hardly die for a righteous man; though perhaps for the good man someone would even dare to die. But God demonstrates His own love toward us, in that while we were yet sinners, Christ died for us. Much more then, having now been justified by His blood, we shall be saved from the wrath of God through Him.

I Peter 2:21-24
For you have been called for this purpose, since Christ also suffered for you, leaving you an example for you to follow in His steps, WHO COMMITTED NO SIN, NOR WAS ANY DECEIT FOUND IN HIS MOUTH; and while being reviled, He did not revile in return; while suffering, He uttered no threats, but kept entrusting Himself to Him who judges righteously; and He himself bore our sins in His body on the cross, that we might die to sin and live to righteousness; for by His wounds you were healed.

For more edification, read Rev. Mark D. Roberts’ observations on Christ’s seven sayings from the cross.

But the best news is that Christ is alive (more reflections to come for Easter)!

Putting Iraq in Perspective

Posted on March 20th, 2008 in General, National Politics, World Events | 2 Comments »

Today’s lead editorial in the Wall Street Journal puts our five-year-long war in Iraq in perspective – surveying where we’ve come from, where we are today, and what the near future portends. The editorial, which deserves perusal from beginning to end, concludes:

In our March 18, 2003 editorial on the eve of Iraq’s liberation, we supported the war while noting that “toppling Saddam is a long-term undertaking” and “the U.S. has never been good at nation-building.” We wish we had been wrong on both counts, but our view has always been that nations shouldn’t begin wars they don’t intend to win. And newspapers don’t endorse wars only to walk away when the fighting gets difficult. The U.S. sacrifice in Iraq has been honorable, our soldiers have fought superbly, and the best way — the only way — to honor both is to leave Iraq in victory.

Those who disagree with the last sentence are slowly being revealed as the radical fringe they are. They continue to ignore the success of “The Surge” and General Petraeus’ innovative counter-insurgency strategy. There are many other Americans, however, who are not beyond persuasion.

Perhaps they will get a glimpse of the coverage of the Vets for Freedom National Heroes Tour (H/T Michelle Malkin) as the noble band continues to roll from coast to coast. My only regret is the Tour won’t be coming to Colorado.

But El Presidente has the local scoop, with a grand roundup of the 5th anniversary in Colorado – including poignant stories, tales of heroism, news of soaring re-enlistments out of “duty to country,” and a reminder of the face of the local anti-war movement.

With so many other distractions swirling around us – from the frivolous to the often serious – it’s easy to forget about a far-off place in Iraq now that the stabilizing country has mostly disappeared off the front pages of media outlets. I appreciated these reminders today, and I hope you will, too.

Benigno on Governor’s Reform

Posted on March 20th, 2008 in Colorado Politics, Education, General, My Life | No Comments »

My close Independence Institute colleague Pam Benigno was interviewed by Denver’s Channel 7 for a story aired last night about Gov. Bill Ritter’s sweeping new education reform plan. You can go here to read the story and watch the video.

Bracketology

Posted on March 20th, 2008 in General, My Life, Random and Miscellaneous, Sports and Leisure | No Comments »

When it comes to March Madness, the truth is I never learn. No matter whether I follow the season closely or guess at random, my picks are always mediocre at best. Yet each year I come back to the NCAA Tournament Brackets like a sheep to the slaughter.

This year is no different. I filled out two different brackets on ESPN, made picks on Facebook’s CBS and Sports Illustrated applications, and even decided to accept the McCain Basketball Brackets challenge.

We’re only a couple hours away from the first game tipping off. How long before my brackets implode in failure? It’s just one more piece of the fun and entertainment of March Madness.

Passion Week: Thursday

Posted on March 20th, 2008 in Christianity and Faith, Commemorative, General | No Comments »

Today we remember the Last Supper and Christ’s betrayal. Though there are many passages to choose from, in particular I am reminded of the Savior’s ultimate example of service and his incomparably fervent prayer (both from the New American Standard Bible):

John 13:3-5
Jesus, knowing that the Father had given all things into His hands, and that He had come forth from God, and was going back to God, rose from supper, and laid aside His garments; and taking a towel, He girded Himself about. Then He poured water into the basin, and began to wash the disciples’ feet, and to wipe them with the towel with which He was girded.

Luke 22:41-44
And He withdrew from them about a stone’s throw, and He knelt down and began to pray, saying, “Father, if Thou art willing, remove this cup from Me; yet not My will, but Thine be done.” Now an angel from heaven appeared to Him, strengthening Him. And being in agony He was praying very fervently; and His sweat became like drops of blood, falling down upon the ground.